Dixieland

Dixieland is the earliest style of recorded jazz, rooted in New Orleans in the first two decades of the 20th century and built on collective improvisation: a trumpet or cornet plays the lead, a clarinet weaves a countermelody above it, and a trombone slides beneath, all at once, over a rhythm section of banjo, tuba or string bass, piano and drums. The name is used for three overlapping things — early New Orleans jazz itself, the white bands that first recorded it, and the revival bands that have played it since the 1940s, often called "trad jazz".

Dixieland grew out of ragtime, blues and brass-band music, and it led directly to the big bands of the swing era. This guide separates it from those neighbours, explains why many musicians prefer the terms "New Orleans jazz" or "traditional jazz", and lists the recordings and tunes worth knowing. To hear how a banjo-and-clarinet front line reads to a machine, run a clip through our free AI music genre detector.

At its heart, Dixieland is a band of five to eight musicians playing a march, a rag, a blues or a popular song with everyone improvising at the same time. The trumpet or cornet states the melody plainly, with some ornament. The clarinet plays fast, florid lines around it, filling the gaps and decorating the top. The trombone plays a lower countermelody, often with the slides and smears called "tailgate" style. Underneath, the rhythm section keeps a steady, buoyant beat. The result is polyphony — several independent lines that fit together — rather than one soloist backed by a band.

Solo choruses exist, especially after Louis Armstrong made them central in the mid-1920s, but the defining moments in a Dixieland performance are the ensemble choruses, particularly the final "out chorus", where the whole front line plays together at full volume. Arrangements are mostly worked out by ear and by tradition: everyone knows the tune, the order of strains and their role.

The term itself has a complicated history. "Dixie" refers to the American South, and the word reached the public through the Original Dixieland Jass Band, a white New Orleans group. Many Black New Orleans musicians and later historians preferred "New Orleans jazz" or "traditional jazz", partly because the word carries Confederate associations and partly because the label was later attached to commercial revival bands rather than to the founders of the music. In practice, "Dixieland" today usually means the revival style; "New Orleans jazz" usually means the original music and its local tradition.

New Orleans around 1900 had an unusual mix: brass bands that played for parades and funerals, Creole musicians with formal training, Black musicians playing the blues, dance halls, and a constant flow of ragtime sheet music and Caribbean rhythms through the port. Cornetist Buddy Bolden, active roughly from the mid-1890s until 1907, is remembered as the first famous player of the new, louder and bluesier style, though he was never recorded. Bands led by Freddie Keppard, Joe "King" Oliver and Kid Ory, and pianist-composer Jelly Roll Morton, carried it forward.

The first jazz recordings were made not by these pioneers but by the Original Dixieland Jass Band, a white quintet from New Orleans led by cornetist Nick LaRocca. In February 1917 in New York they recorded "Livery Stable Blues" and "Dixie Jass Band One-Step" for the Victor company, and the record became a commercial sensation. Their "Tiger Rag" became one of the most-played tunes in jazz. The ODJB's success opened the door for others: the New Orleans Rhythm Kings recorded in 1922–1923, and in 1923 King Oliver's Creole Jazz Band, with a young Louis Armstrong on second cornet, made the recordings — "Dipper Mouth Blues", "Canal Street Blues" — that are now treated as the definitive documents of the New Orleans ensemble style.

By then many New Orleans musicians had moved north, and Chicago became the music's centre. Armstrong's Hot Five and Hot Seven recordings (1925–1928) transformed the form by putting the virtuoso soloist at the centre, while Morton's Red Hot Peppers (from 1926) showed how carefully composed and arranged the style could be. Young white Chicago musicians — Bix Beiderbecke with the Wolverines, and the "Austin High Gang" around Eddie Condon — developed a slightly faster, more hard-driving variant often called Chicago style.

In the 1930s the big bands of the swing era took over the dance market, and the small-band style seemed old-fashioned. A revival began around 1940. Record collectors and writers went looking for the music's roots; trumpeter Bunk Johnson was rediscovered and recorded; in San Francisco, Lu Watters' Yerba Buena Jazz Band played the King Oliver repertoire for a new audience. Critics who defended the old style against bebop were mocked as "moldy figs", and the two camps argued through the 1940s.

The revival became a mass movement in Britain, where "trad" bands led by Chris Barber, Ken Colyer, Humphrey Lyttelton, Kenny Ball and Acker Bilk filled clubs in the 1950s. Lyttelton's "Bad Penny Blues" (1956), Bilk's "Stranger on the Shore" and Kenny Ball's "Midnight in Moscow" (both 1961) reached the pop charts. In the US, clarinettist Pete Fountain and trumpeter Al Hirt became national names, and in New Orleans, Preservation Hall opened in 1961 to give older local musicians a place to play. The tradition continues today in New Orleans clubs, festivals worldwide and the city's brass bands.

What identifies a Dixieland performance:

• Tempo: anything from slow blues and funeral dirges around 70–90 BPM to stomps and one-steps above 200 BPM; the typical medium-bright tempo sits around 140–190 BPM.
• Rhythm: a strong two-beat feel in older and revival styles, with the tuba or bass and the banjo marking beats one and three; Chicago style and later bands move toward an even four-to-the-bar.
• Collective improvisation: three melodic lines at once — lead (trumpet or cornet), obbligato (clarinet) and tailgate counterline (trombone).
• Forms: multi-strain marches and rags (A, B and C strains with a key change), twelve-bar blues and 32-bar popular songs.
• Breaks and stop-time: the band stops for one or two bars while a soloist plays a short phrase; "Dipper Mouth Blues" and "Tiger Rag" are full of them.
• Harmony: simple triads and dominant sevenths, borrowed from ragtime and marches; much less chromatic than later jazz.
• Tone: bright, brassy and acoustic; early recordings are thin and mid-range-heavy because of acoustic-horn recording before 1925.

Dixieland next to the styles before and after it:

A classic Dixieland band is split into a front line of horns and a rhythm section.

• Cornet or trumpet — carries the melody and leads the ensemble. King Oliver, Louis Armstrong, Bix Beiderbecke, Nick LaRocca, Bunk Johnson and, in the revival, Kenny Ball and Al Hirt.
• Clarinet — the high, agile counter-voice: Johnny Dodds, Jimmie Noone, Larry Shields of the ODJB, Barney Bigard, Pete Fountain, Acker Bilk. The soprano saxophone of Sidney Bechet sometimes took this role, often taking the lead.
• Trombone — harmony and bass-register counterpoint with slides and smears: Kid Ory, Honoré Dutrey, Jack Teagarden, Chris Barber.
• Banjo — a loud, percussive chordal instrument that cut through acoustic recording; replaced by guitar in later and swing-influenced bands.
• Tuba or string bass — tuba (or sousaphone) in the brass-band tradition and early recordings, string bass increasingly from the late 1920s.
• Piano — ragtime-based accompaniment; Lil Hardin Armstrong in Oliver's and Armstrong's bands, Jelly Roll Morton as leader.
• Drums — woodblocks, cymbal chokes and press rolls rather than the continuous ride cymbal of later jazz; Baby Dodds is the model.

Sound quality affects how this music is heard today. Recordings before 1925 were made acoustically, into a horn, with no microphones; bass drums and string basses were often left out or muffled. The electrical recordings from the Hot Five era onward capture far more of the rhythm section.

• New Orleans jazz — the original ensemble style of King Oliver, Kid Ory, Jelly Roll Morton and Sidney Bechet.
• Chicago style — 1920s white musicians in Chicago; faster, more solo-centred, often with saxophone and a four-beat feel. Eddie Condon, Bud Freeman, Frank Teschemacher, Bix Beiderbecke.
• Revival (US) — from around 1940: Lu Watters, Turk Murphy, Bunk Johnson, the Dukes of Dixieland, Pete Fountain, Al Hirt.
• Trad jazz (UK and Europe) — the 1950s–60s British boom: Ken Colyer, Chris Barber, Humphrey Lyttelton, Kenny Ball, Acker Bilk. Barber's band also helped launch the skiffle craze through Lonnie Donegan.
• New Orleans brass bands — the parade and funeral tradition that fed Dixieland, alive today in bands like the Dirty Dozen and Rebirth, which mix in funk and hip-hop.
• Big-band Dixieland — swing-era orchestras that kept the repertoire, such as Bob Crosby's band and its small group, the Bob Cats.
• Close relatives — gypsy jazz took the same 1920s–30s song repertoire into a string-band format; swing and the big band grew directly out of the 1920s bands.

Landmark recordings and tunes that every Dixieland band still plays:

Ragtime is the closest ancestor and the easiest to confuse. The difference is improvisation. A ragtime piece like "Maple Leaf Rag" is composed and published as sheet music, and a pianist plays what is written. Dixieland bands took the multi-strain form and the syncopation of ragtime, added the blues, and improvised over it as a group. Ragtime also has a straighter, more even rhythmic feel; Dixieland starts to bounce and swing.

Swing is what came next. The swing era replaced the small band with sections of saxophones, trumpets and trombones playing written arrangements, replaced collective improvisation with solos framed by the arrangement, and smoothed the rhythm into an even four beats with string bass and guitar. A swing band sounds like an orchestra; a Dixieland band sounds like a conversation. For the format that took over, see our guide to the big band.

Against the blues, the relationship is one of ingredients. Twelve-bar blues forms and blue notes run all through Dixieland, but the blues as a genre is a song tradition centred on a singer and guitar or piano. Our comparison of jazz vs blues goes into that shared ground in more depth.

An audio model has distinctive cues for this style: clarinet runs in the upper register, trumpet and trombone playing simultaneously rather than in harmonised sections, the dry plucked attack of a banjo on every beat, and a tuba or bass outlining a two-beat pattern. Old recordings add their own fingerprint — a narrow frequency range, surface noise and almost no low end — which a model may treat as a signal of age in its own right.

Use the Genre AI music genre detector on a clean modern recording of a trad band as well as on a 1920s transfer and compare the results; noisy historic audio is a hard case for any classifier.

What is Dixieland jazz?

Is Dixieland the same as New Orleans jazz?

What was the first jazz recording?

What is the difference between Dixieland and ragtime?

What is the difference between Dixieland and swing?

What instruments are in a Dixieland band?

What is trad jazz?